For those interested, this is my review of Red Dead Redemption from Rockstar:
Historically, games set in the "wild west" have been mediocre at best. I'm not sure why this is true, but game makers just haven't had luck making a hit based on the wild west.
Rockstar changes this strange truth with one the finest games I have played. A simple way to describe this game is "GTA IV set in the wild west," and this is true: same mission structure, same engine, and very similar combat. Not that this a bad label, as all of the elements lifted from GTA IV are rock solid and make the game a ton of fun. But Red Dead goes beyond this label by creating a western landscape that is gorgeous, with environments that go far beyond the concrete jungle.
Story wise, the game has a slow start and the protagonist's intentions could be made clearer, but this only a minor flaw in a story that is gripping in action and presents some very interesting themes regarding human nature and change under the umbrella of the end of the wild west. The story only gets better because of memorable cast of characters backed with top notch voice acting and a haunting soundtrack.
On the multiplayer side of things, Free Roam opens up the entire game world to you and bunch of your friends. There are so many challenges to pursue within Free Roam, an experience that is only enhanced when riding with a bunch of your other friends. In the actual modes, Red Dead puts the western twist on your familiar game types. While this isn't bad, I feel as if there was potential for some really unique game types.
Overall, it is understandable that someone who played a crapton of GTA would feel underwhelmed by this game, but a lot of that feeling could be a result just of preference with a certain setting. I highly recommend everyone play Red Dead simply because it is such a great game in all aspects and is guaranteed to keep you busy for a loooooong time.
Not the best review, but it's my first ever